Home » How To's » How to Shift the Diet Mentality

How to Shift the Diet Mentality

By Katherine Kimber, Registered Dietitian | March 19, 2020

The diet mentality is a false belief that weight loss creates health, confidence, happiness, and success. This mentality steals joys from life by saying you should delay your dreams until you have lost weight. It’s the voice you hear over and over which categorises food into good and bad or healthy and unhealthy. 

So perhaps you’re becoming aware that following rigid rules around eating in pursuit of weight loss is not serving you. Maybe it hasn’t resulted in long term weight loss after all? Maybe it’s ultimately led to binge eating, weight gain, food obsession and regularly eating past the point of comfortable fullness? 

Intuitive Eating is an approach that ditches the pursuit of weight loss. Because that pursuit can cause all sorts of complex issues with food. Instead, it helps you heal your relationship with food and lets your weight settle in a comfortable place that’s natural and healthy for you.

When beginning to pursue the Intuitive Eating, the idea of letting go of dieting tools, food rules and restrictions can feel quite uncomfortable. You may be trying to let go of dieting and restriction but struggle with thoughts like:

  • “I am honouring my hunger and eating as much as I need, but still feel really guilty.”
  • “I am aware of hunger cues but I struggle to honour them.”
  • “I get that I need to stop restriction, but when I give myself an inch I take a mile.”
  • “I can’t stop comparing what I eat to other peoples.”

I hear you. 

As a Registered Dietitian, and Certified Intuitive Eating Counsellor, I support many people through overcoming complex and problematic relationships with food. I have pulled together some ideas that might help you to shift the diet mentality.

Think of letting go of the diet mentality like weaning a baby

You don’t suddenly switch a baby from breastmilk or formula to solid foods overnight. It’s a weaning process. If you’re at the stage where you know you need to ditch dieting (restrictive eating to pursue weight loss) in order to overcome a problematic relationship with food, it can feel very frustrating. You’re “consciously incompetent”, meaning you’re becoming aware of what to do, but you can’t do it just yet. 

Imagine if you suddenly took milk away from a baby when they didn’t yet have the full skills to eat solid foods. They would likely get very hungry and upset. The same happens if you suddenly ditch dieting tools. You have nothing else to hold you just yet, and you’ve likely not learnt and practiced the skills to fully let go of dieting tools, rules and restrictions. This takes time, and that’s where self-compassion needs to come in…

Self-Compassion is Key to Ditching the Diet Mentality

  • Think about what your self talk is sounding like right now? 
  • Would you speak like this to a friend or loved one? 
  • How would you feel if someone said these things to you?

Compassion is the desire we have to help alleviate suffering in friends/children/animals. Self-compassion is directing that inwards to ourselves.

Why does it matter? 

Having a higher level of self-compassion has been linked to a number of health enhancing behaviours, in particular, in relation to food behaviours. That includes, having fewer binge eating symptoms and body image concerns. It can basically help with those judgy voices that try to sabotage you moving through improving your relationship with food. e.g. “I’m such a failure”, “I can’t believe I did that”, “I’ve ruined my day now”, “I’m not worthy”, “I’m disgusting”. 

So if your self-talk is negative, think about how you might respond to a friend going through a similar tough time?

If your self talk is something like: 

“I am aware of hunger cues but I struggle to honour them”

My response would be something like… 

“The diet talk is really strong right now and we know that’s been a default mentality for you for a long time. No wonder you find it tough to honour your body’s natural signals. I know that many other people find it tough too. What’s great is that you’re becoming more aware of your hunger signals and listening to them. It sounds as though you’re doing really well with that. It’s great that we now have new information that you find it difficult to honour them… is this something you would like to explore further?”

Hopefully that’s given you some insight into some of the common mind battles that many people face when they are beginning to ditch the diet mentality. These are normal, and it will take time to wean off of restrictive thoughts or guilt round eating certain foods.

The more you practice honouring your own natural hunger, fullness and satisfaction signals the more confident you will feel in letting go of the physical tools. These tools are things like counting calories, eating at certain times of day, compensating for food eaten by exercising more or cutting back elsewhere. A lot of self-compassion is required and if you’re struggling, additional support from a qualified practitioner may be beneficial.

Welcome to Nude Nutrition

I am Katherine Kimber, a Registered Dietitian, and Certified Intuitive Eating Counsellor with a first-class Undergraduate and Masters’s degree from Kings College London.

Are you fed up with not knowing what you should or shouldn’t be eating? Perhaps relying on external tools such as the time of day, points systems, calorie tracking or rigid rules to show you the way.

If you’re ready to get out of your head when it comes to food decisions, and more into your body then you’ve come to the right place. I’m here to strip the nonsense, so you can feel better in your body and figure out a sustainable approach to movement and nutrition.

Nude Nutrition on social

7 Steps To Find Food Peace & Food Freedom

If you struggle with yo-yo dieting, emotional eating, comfort eating, binge eating, compulsive overeating or feeling guilty when you eat, this 20-minute audio download with actionable steps in a workbook is right for you.

More articles from Katherine at Nude Nutrition

How to Navigate Emotional Eating

How to Navigate Emotional Eating

Are you wondering how to best navigate emotional eating? This article written by Registered Dietitian Katherine Kimber, outlines what it is, aims to help you understand its roots, and ways to manage it.

read more
Overeating When Working From Home – How To Stop

Overeating When Working From Home – How To Stop

With Coronovirus taking over, many of us are having to work from home. Whilst this can feel novel and exciting for some, it can also come with that dreaded fear… The FRIDGE! Maybe thoughts like... “How will I be able to control my eating?” “I’m home alone and nobody...

read more
Plus Size Dating – Beyond Appearance

Plus Size Dating – Beyond Appearance

Dating seems to be considered an emotional experience, but a necessary hurdle if you want to find a partnership. And when you’re plus-sized (or if your appearance doesn’t conform to mainstream beauty standards in other ways), dating can seem riddled with even more challenges. So how can you navigate the dating scene when your body doesn’t conform to societal standards?

read more

Client Stories

Ready to change your life?

Get inspired by recent clients who have transformed their lives. From battling with binge eating, feeling addicted to food, and yo-yo dieting, to normalised eating and food freedom. 

From an 8 year battle with “binge eating”, to “my life no longer revolves around food”.

Miss G – “Reclaim Your Intuition” + ongoing support  

Sarah thought she was addicted to sugar, mostly chocolate. So much so, she was going to spend thousands of pounds to go to a sugar addiction rehab centre, leaving her 9 month old son behind. Her eating habits were out of control, and her weight was increasing rapidly. She thought a Dietitian would just tell her what to eat and was hesitant… however, realised this is far from the truth! She has now realised she does not have an addiction, now has normalised her eating, she can be around chocolate without needing to eat it, has more structure, more awareness, is more in tune with her natural hunger signals.

Miss M – “Reclaim Your Intuition” programme 

From a lifelong battle with binge eating, dieting, and an attempt to end her life earlier this year because of it, to being able to look forward to social occasions without agonising over menus, being more present with friends and family, feeling less isolated, and a sense of absolute freedom around food. “This programme has changed my life”.  

Mrs P – “Reclaim Your Intuition” + ongoing support  

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *